Not only are these Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies super cute, but they’re special to me because I’ve loved the traditional Necco Sweethearts since I was a kid. It just doesn’t feel like Valentine’s Day without them. When they changed the formula awhile ago, I was really disappointed because the flavors just weren’t the same.
When they had their 150th Anniversary and brought back the original recipe, I was so excited!! I pretty much bought every bag I could find. It wouldn’t be Valentine’s Day without conversation hearts so I made these really cute cookies to celebrate the holiday. I hope you enjoy!
***This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission (at no extra cost to you) if you click a link and purchase something. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Click to see my full disclosure policy.***
- Sugar Cookies:
- 4¼-inch heart cookies
- Medium consistency royal icing (i.e., slightly stiff, but able to heal) in white and AmeriColor Deep Pink, Orange, Lemon Yellow, Leaf Green, and Violet
- Stiff royal icing in AmeriColor Super Red
- Disposable piping bags
- Couplers and icing tips #1 and #2
Decorating Conversation Heart Sugar Cookies
Subscribe to my newsletter to get notifications about all of the cookies I am making for my Valentine’s Day Cookie Week. You will also receive a free Checklist for Cookie Decorating Supplies when you subscribe!
Use a #2 tip to outline and fill the cookies with medium consistency icing. Use a toothpick to encourage the icing to move to the outline and to pop any large bubbles. Gently shake the cookie to ensure the royal icing levels out (i.e., “heals”).
Let the conversation heart sugar cookies sit and crust for at least 1 hour.
Use a #1 tip to write Valentine’s Day messages on the cookie in red royal icing. Examples of messages include:
- I Love You
- Kiss Me
- I <3 You
- Be Mine
- True Love
Let the icing dry uncovered for 6-8 hours (or overnight). They are now ready to be given as a sweet message to your valentine.
Do you love Necco Sweethearts or are you one of the many who think they are “chalky”? Let me know in the comments below.